Muse Percussion Reviews
I have been using Muse percussion for over two years now and it has worked well. However, one major issue that recently started over the last few releases is that a crash cymbal choke is WAY too loud. If the Musesounds team could look into this issue it would be great.
Muse Perc sounds great right now, but the sound of the older version worked better for some of my other arrangements since very particular adjustments had been made on them to cater to that specific version of Muse Perc. Muse Brass recently added a "Download previous version" feature on MuseHub. I'm curious if the same might be possible for Muse Perc someday?
for some reason having a 32nd or 64th tremolo for a cymbal roll on the drum kit does not work any more.... i have tried everything to make it play back as it did before but no success... please revert this update or fix the issue somehow !! i was much happier with the drum kit before :(
Developer Response: Thank you for the feedback. We've passed the Muse Percussion cymbal roll issue on to the MuseSounds team.
The instruments I'm talking about are the bass drum, timbales, and chimes. After the new update, the timbales and chimes aren't loud enough on the louder dynamics. The bass drum has always been quiet on dynamics like ff - fff. I would like this fixed please.
Developer Response: Thank you for the feedback. Chime levels have been fixed in the latest Muse Percussion update, so please update through MuseHub. The MuseSounds team is also working on bass drum and timbale levels.
During a fortissimo dynamics, I cannot hear a single note from a bass drum/cymbals unless it is being placed with an accent. Please revert back immediately their playback setup even without putting an articulation on each note of the aforementioned instruments
Developer Response: This issue has been fixed in Muse Percussion 1.0.3, so please be sure to update to the latest version through MuseHub. Thanks!
Once again, Muse Group has sent out an update we didn't need and broken things - in this case, the chimes. Suddenly, Chimes are OVERPOWERED compared to everything else. Old pieces of mine that use chimes are now so blaringly loud that it is distracting. Plus, when I try to alter the dynamics to tone them down, they fade to non-existence. There is no happy medium. Please revert to the old chimes.
Some instruments like the chimes became really loud since the new update came out, which makes some of my scores sound weird or bad. Also, the splash cymbal on the regular drum kit just doesn't make sound.
Developer Response: Thank you for the detailed feedback. The MuseSounds team is aware of the issues with the Muse Percussion update and is working on fixes.
Positives: Subfolders, trap kit bass drum not ridiculously loud anymore, gong and tam-tam rolls are smoother, dampen on release, secco and let ring sound flags for sleigh bells, bass drum, mark tree, bell tree (some instruments dampen on release, secco and let ring needs to be separated by modify sound and playing techniques), glockenspiel, crotales, timpani (dampen on release doesn't work as intended on rolls). Negatives: Suspended cymbal release holds out and has this sizzle sound and it's annoying, most of the instruments are way louder or softer than before for example the rimshots at forte on the timbales causes the audio to peak out
Developer Response: Thank you for the detailed feedback. The MuseSounds team is aware of the issues with the Muse Percussion update and is working on fixes.
I hate to be someone that just complains, but the percussion sounds very weird after the update, and in some cases, worse, especially the mallets (glockenspiel, marimba, etc). Suspended cymbal also sounds off too. I feel there was no need to change the sound of most of these instruments.
Developer Response: Thank you for the detailed feedback. The MuseSounds team is aware of the issues with the Muse Percussion update and is working on fixes.
The tubular bells sound so strange in the new update. Other sounds are fine but just the chimes.
Developer Response: Thank you for the detailed feedback. The MuseSounds team is aware of the issues with the Muse Percussion update and is working on fixes.
But the snare drum with snares off settings while playing consecutive fast notes after each other there’s a glitch in sounds; it doesn’t play the sample as it should but there’s like an annoying click.
Everything sounds great, just the fact that there are only 3 concert toms and the snare drum sound is weirdly reverberated and barely can be heard under other percussion/wind instruments, other than that everything else sounds great (ESPECIALLY the Timpani)
Definitely a step up from MS Basic.
Mostly WAY better than the default sounds. There is a few however that are not the best. The glockenspiel is far to soft and dynamics don't work well. The timpani's sound really mushes together. The chimes don't play anything above the high G for some reason. Many other instrument are missing like finger cymbals and ocean drum.
Good, most things sound good expect for a lot of the keyboards, the glockenspiel sounds like a bell kit, and a glockenspiel is different from a bell kit. The marimba sounds like it was played with hard mallets, i wish there was a way to change whether the marimba was played with hard mallets or soft mallets because a lot of things just don't sound good with hard mallets. (EDIT: JUST FOUND OUT YOU CAN CHANGE IT, THANK YOU MUSESCORE)
Using mixed percussion was great until this last update. Mixed percussion is a lot quieter than it should be if the dynamic is below F, but my biggest issue is that buzz rolls no longer work on snare for mixed percussion.
Percussion. Hand Cymbals too quiet and unnatural. Snare if fine, suspension cymbals are awesome, bass drum louder than others.
The drums sound great
Glockenspiel range limited to C5 while orchestral glockenspiels often feature 3 octaves of range up to F5. Doesn't sound that good either.
The trap kit in particular isn't well balanced — the bass drum is way too loud compared to everything else.
There's a problem with Mixed Percussion whereby it is effectively inaudible below mf. The Mixed Percussion instrument sounds are significantly quieter than those of equivalent individual instruments at the same dynamic markings. I've tried bumping the volume up in the mixer, but it doesn't help. I've contacted support. Hopefully they can fix this, because the sounds are great, but currently unusable on a Mixed Percussion stave for me due to the glitch.
I just wrote an entire review and accidently deleted it, so I’ll make this brief. The sounds are amazing, I recommend this product. But, I think the new notehead functionality in the newest update may have accidently cause an issue with playback. Some specific notes just cut out and don’t make any noise. These are notes I copy pasted from another percussion track. Let’s say I have a snare and taiko part in a song. I’ll copy paste a rhythm from the taiko onto the snaare part, and that won’t make noise because the soundfont for snare drum ONLY has snare sounds. It will see the taiko notes and just not play them because it doesn’t have taiko sounds even though it uses perfectly normal noteheads. I went to the MS Basic soundfont, and the notes that don’t work on Muse Persussion play the sound it was copy pasted from. So, it would play the taiko sound on the snare drum part on MS Basic, and on Muse Percussion, it wouldn’t even make a sound. And copying is a lot more efficient than inputing everything manually. This wasn’t an issue before the update. I reaaly hope that this can be fixed. Thank you if you took the time to read this.
Lately, for some reason, my suspended cymbal crescendo rolls have been sounding rough, with there being a sudden jump in emphasis and volume around the end; this wasn't an issue before recently, with the rolls sounding smooth as intended; Idk what happened
These are miles better compared to the vanilla soundfonts, and its criminal that they’re free. The vibraphones & marimas sound amazing, and mix incredibly well with any instrument. 9/10, would recommend.